Story of Yahoo!’s role in Jailing Chinese Journalist Breaks Internationally..

Glutter’s Hong Kong

I don’t know who leaked this. Whoever it is. That person made a huge and immediate impact.

I would like to shake your hand one day.

Original Press Release: Yahoo Provided Information that jailed Chinese journalist.

Two nights ago, I answered a list of questions about Internet Law, Privacy Policy, ISPs in Hong Kong, China and Hong Kong Business Legalities and whether Yahoo! Hong Kong and Yahoo! China shared the same management. (It’s probably not things people expect me to know but I do.)

While my friend Na*im did some server locating and told me everything he knows about hosts and servers as well as HK privacy law.

I followed it up with a few more phone calls, messenger convos and more research to cross check information. Then at about 2am I sent it off and i went to bed.

Today I got an email from someone who said he saw the story on the front page of Financial Times European Edition….

Then I thought I would search for a similar story on the news feeds to post on Glutter…

344 articles around the world so far and counting.

I hope this story makes a difference, as much is needed for a wide
spread acknowledgement that the backbone of Internet Censorship in
China is provided by American Technology, American Companies and hence
American Capital. Not to mention, hopefully this prevents another
dissident lulled into a false sense of security because they are using
"foreign" service and email providers.

Julien from RSF suggested I put my participation up on here:

He said, "You did a great job Yan. Your help was Essential and Quick. You can Quote me on your Blog."

I appreciate receiving the suggestion and permission because otherwise I would not have thought it appropiate. It’s nice to be able to record it for myself as this is surely one of the most important things I have participated in to date.

A few years ago, part of my job included acting as a censor blocking the news of the 10th Anniversary of the 1989 Student Democratic Movement and its subsequent crackdown to be discussed or read about on China.com and HongKong.com. It took me five months to quit and five years to blow the whistle, and even after all that time it took ounces of courage.

I don’t know who leaked this. Whoever it is. That person made a huge and immediate impact.

Good Luck.

I hope I get to shake your hand one day.

—-

Results 130 of about 345 related articles.  Search took 0.51 seconds.   

Yahoo sidesteps claim of complicity
Aljazeera.net, Qatar – 4 hours ago
Internet
giant Yahoo has sidestepped claims that it aided China in the jailing
of a journalist after he sent an email from a Yahoo account, saying it
has to
Yahoo says its country sites abide by local laws; no comment on
Forbes – 5 hours ago
HONG
KONG (AFX) – Yahoo Inc said its country sites operate within local laws
and regulations after allegations that it aided China in the jailing of
a
Yahoo! sidesteps claims it aided China to jail journalist
Mail & Guardian Online, South Africa – 5 hours ago
Internet
giant Yahoo! on Thursday sidestepped claims that it aided China in the
jailing of a journalist after he sent an email from
Yahoo! on defensive over jailed Chinese journalist
Times Online, UK – 5 hours ago
The
American internet company Yahoo! defended itself today against
criticism that it supplied information to the Chinese authorities
Yahoo accused of betraying journalist
Monsters and Critics.com, UK – 6 hours ago
HONG
KONG, China (UPI) — The Hong Kong office of Yahoo provided Chinese
police with information leading to the jailing of a journalist, media
watchdog
Yahoo Accused of Aiding China in Arrest
Los Angeles Times, CA – 9 hours ago
Reporters
Without Borders says the Internet portal firm handed over data to
authorities that led them to a cyber dissident. By Ching
Yahoo accused over journalist’s jailing
The Age (subscription), Australia – 10 hours ago
Internet
giant Yahoo Inc has defended itself against accusations that it
supplied data to Chinese authorities which led to the imprisonment of a
journalist
Yahoo defends China action
Australian, Australia – 11 hours ago
By
John Ruwitch in Hong Kong. INTERNET giant Yahoo Inc defended itself
today against accusations that it supplied data to Chinese
Costly foot in the door
Financial Times, UK – 14 hours ago
A
statement this week from Reporters Without Borders will make unsettling
reading for foreign companies eager to join China’s internet boom.
Yahoo ‘aided jailing of journalist’
Guardian Unlimited, UK – 16 hours ago
The
internet portal Yahoo! provided crucial information that helped Chinese
authorities imprison an outspoken local journalist, a
Yahoo!’s Chinese Trial Aid No Help to Reputation
TheStreet.com – 17 hours ago
Yahoo!
(YHOO:Nasdaq – commentary – research – Cramer’s Take) has discovered
the risk inherent in gaining a strong foothold in China
Web of complicity
Telegraph.co.uk, United Kingdom – 17 hours ago
Yahoo,
the American internet giant, stands accused of helping Beijing to send
a dissident journalist to prison for 10 years. The
Yahoo ‘helps China track down and jail dissident’
Telegraph.co.uk, United Kingdom – 17 hours ago
By
Richard Spencer, China Correspondent. Yahoo, the American internet
firm, was accused yesterday of helping China’s state security
Yahoo! ‘helped to jail journalist’
Times Online, UK – 17 hours ago
THE
US internet giant Yahoo! handed information to the Chinese authorities
which led to a ten-year jail sentence on a journalist
‘Yahoo helped China convict journalist’
Times of India, India – 22 hours ago
BEIJING:
A French media watchdog group said information provided by Internet
powerhouse Yahoo Inc helped Chinese authorities convict and jail a
writer, who had
Yahoo accused of helping China convict journalist
MSN Money – 22 hours ago
Reporters
Without Borders, the Paris-based press freedom watchdog, on Wednesday
accused Yahoo, the US internet portal, of helping Chinese authorities
to catch
Did Semel’s Yahoo! Help Beijing Jail Reporter?
Forbes – 23 hours ago
Yahoo! (nasdaq: YHOO – news – people ) has been accused of enabling Beijing in its jailing of a journalist. International media
Yahoo! accused of aiding secret police
Sydney Morning Herald (subscription), Australia – Sep 7, 2005
Beijing:
The American internet company Yahoo! provided China’s secret police
with information that got a journalist a 10-year jail
Firms face moral dilemma in China
BBC News, UK – Sep 7, 2005
Media
watchdog Reporters Without Borders has accused Yahoo of being "a police
informant for the Chinese regime", following allegations that
information
Did Yahoo Help Send a Chinese Journalist to Jail?
PC World – Sep 7, 2005
A
media watch group alleged this week that Yahoo gave the Chinese
government access to e-mails sent from a journalist’s personal Web
account, helping land him
Yahoo accused of helping Chinese jail journalist
Telegraph.co.uk, United Kingdom – Sep 7, 2005
Internet
search giant Yahoo has been accused of helping Chinese authorities jail
a journalist for 10 years. Shi Tao had complained
Yahoo helped Chinese to prosecute journalist
International Herald Tribune, France – Sep 7, 2005
BEIJING
The Internet giant Yahoo provided information that helped Chinese state
security officials convict a Chinese journalist for leaking state
secrets to a
Yahoo blamed for jailing of Chinese reporter
Times Online, UK – Sep 7, 2005
By
Philippe Naughton, Times Online. The internet company Yahoo! has come
under attack from an international press watchdog for supplying
Yahoo! assists Chinese dissident conviction
Register, UK – Sep 7, 2005
Media
watchdog Reporters Without Borders has accused Yahoo! of going out of
its way to help Chinese authorities to convict a "dissident
journalist".
Watchdog says Yahoo! gave China data on jailed journalist
Mail & Guardian Online, South Africa – Sep 7, 2005
Internet
giant Yahoo! supplied information to the Chinese government that led to
the jailing of journalist Shi Tao for 10 years, international
Yahoo ‘helped jail China writer’
BBC News, UK – Sep 7, 2005
Internet
giant Yahoo has been accused of supplying information to China which
led to the jailing of a journalist for "divulging state secrets".
Yahoo grassed up journalist to Chinese cops
Inquirer, UK – Sep 6, 2005
SEARCH
OUTFIT Yahoo! has helped send a Chinese business journalist, who sent a
‘pro-democracy’ story to the foreign press, to jail for more than 10
years.
Yahoo accused of helping China convict journalist
Financial Times, UK – Sep 6, 2005
By
Financial Times reporters. A media watchdog accused Yahoo, the US
internet portal, of assisting Chinese authorities in the conviction

Update 2: Group: Yahoo Helped China Jail Journalist
Forbes – Sep 6, 2005
A
French media watchdog said Tuesday that information provided by
Internet powerhouse Yahoo Inc. helped Chinese authorities convict

Yahoo rebuked in Chinese journalist case
San Jose Mercury News, United States – Sep 6, 2005
By
Michael Bazeley. Yahoo has provoked the ire of a media watchdog group
for allegedly giving information to the Chinese government
Group: Yahoo helped China jail journalist
BusinessWeek – Sep 6, 2005
SEP.
6 9:14 PM ET A French media watchdog said Tuesday that information
provided by Internet powerhouse Yahoo Inc. helped Chinese
Group says Yahoo helped jail Chinese journalist
CNET News.com, United States – Sep 6, 2005
A
French media watchdog group claimed Tuesday that Yahoo provided
information that helped Chinese officials convict a journalist accused
of leaking state
Yahoo! ‘gave e-mail details that helped jail Chinese writer’
Independent, UK – Sep 6, 2005
By
Elizabeth Davies. Information supplied by the internet giant Yahoo! to
Chinese intelligence has resulted in the conviction of
Rights group says Yahoo’s cooperation helped China jail journalist
San Jose Mercury News, United States – Sep 6, 2005
BEIJING – A French media watchdog said Tuesday that information provided by Internet icon Yahoo Inc. helped Chinese authorities
Yahoo says it obeyed local law in Chinese journalist case
JURIST – 56 minutes ago
[JURIST]
Internet giant Yahoo [corporate website] defended itself Thursday
against claims that the company aided China in the prosecution and
ten-year
Yahoo Falls From Press’ Grace
Softpedia – 4 hours ago
In
April this year, Chinese journalist Shi Tao was sentenced to 10 years
in prison for sending abroad an e-mail that Chinese authorities alleged
contained
Yahoo says it obeyed Chinese law by turning in e-mails
Infoworld, Netherlands – 4 hours ago
Yahoo
Inc. was only following Chinese law when it provided evidence that
helped land a local journalist a 10-year jail sentence, the company
said Thursday.
Yahoo Snitched on Now-Jailed Chinese Journalist
Marketing Vox News – 5 hours ago
Apparently
joining the ranks of ignoble foreign companies in China scurrying to
please its despotic government with some dastardly deeds of their own
for the
Yahoo Responds On China Journalist Issue
WebProNews, KY – 6 hours ago
Assistance
rendered by Hong Kong-based Yahoo Holdings led to the imprisonment of
Shi Tao for passing a "state secret.". We had to
Yahoo Under Fire Over Jailing of Chinese Journalist
CNSNews.com, VA – 8 hours ago
By
Patrick Goodenough. (CNSNews.com) – Internet giant Yahoo, accused this
week of providing information that helped land a Chinese
Yahoo! says that they have to follow instructions from Chinese
TechWhack, India – 8 hours ago
World’s
most popular web portal Yahoo! recently came under fire from the media
when they were accused for helping Chinese government
China And US Internet Companies
InternetWeek.com, NY – 15 hours ago
As
US Internet companies like Yahoo, Google and Microsoft race to become
the biggest player in the emerging e-commerce market in China, how far
will they be
CHINA: Yahoo gave e-mail account data used to imprison journalist
CPJ Press Freedom Online, NY – 18 hours ago
New
York, September 7, 2005 ­ The Committee to Protect Journalists is
alarmed by news that information provided by Internet giant Yahoo Inc.
Privacy International demands Yahoo boycott
ZDNet.com.au, Australia – 18 hours ago
The
human-rights group is calling for action over claims Yahoo is
‘cheerfully sacrificing human rights in return for a cut of the Chinese
market’.
Yahoo helped jail Chinese Journalist
HardwareGeeks.com – 20 hours ago
Reporters
without Borders said today that Yahoo assisted in the jailing of a
Chinese Journalist. According to court papers filed
Yahoo helped jail Chinese journalist, group says
Computerworld New Zealand, New Zealand – 21 hours ago
A
media watch group is claiming that Yahoo gave the Chinese government
access to emails sent from a journalist’s personal web account, helping
land him a 10
Media watchdog accuses Yahoo of helping Chinese prosecution of
JURIST – 23 hours ago
[JURIST]
An international media watchdog organization has said that internet
company Yahoo [corporate website] divulged information to China that
led to the
Press Freedom Group Says Information from US Internet Company
PolitInfo.com, Germany – 23 hours ago
The
international press advocacy group Reporters Without Borders says the
Internet company Yahoo provided the Chinese authorities with
information that helped
Yahoo! In The Hot Seat With Free Press Advocates
WebProNews, KY – Sep 7, 2005
Reporters
Without Borders is accusing Yahoo! of providing information to the
Chinese government to procure the conviction of a Hong
Google, Yahoo Acting In Questionable Manners
WebProNews, KY – Sep 7, 2005
It
appears as if the business of doing business can cause conglomerate
types to do behave in a manner that some may find questionable.
Yahoo: ‘China police informant’
p2pnet.net, Canada – Sep 7, 2005
p2p
news / p2pnet:- Yahoo ! Holdings (Hong Kong) gave Communist China state
security authorities information that helped identify
Group Alleges Yahoo Helped Jail Chinese Writer
WebProNews, KY – Sep 7, 2005
Reporters
Without Borders claims Yahoo acted as a "police informant," leading to
a writer’s conviction in Beijing. Yahoo paid $1
Yahoo Helped China Imprison Journalist Says Reporters Without
Search Engine Journal – Sep 7, 2005
According
to a report released by Reports Without Borders (Reporters sans
frontieres) Yahoo Holdings (Hong Kong, China) helped China convict a
journalist by
Yahoo accused of helping Chinese Police jail reporter
Web User, UK – Sep 7, 2005
Web
company Yahoo helped Chinese police to jail a journalist by showing
them how to trace an email to his computer, it is claimed.
Yahoo! accused of helping Chinese police to convict journalist
Revolution Magazine, UK – Sep 7, 2005
LONDON
– A press freedom organisation has accused Yahoo! of helping Chinese
police secure the conviction of a journalist for leaking
Group: Yahoo key to writer’s jailing
AZ Central.com, AZ – Sep 7, 2005
BEIJING
– A French media watchdog said Tuesday that information provided by
Internet powerhouse Yahoo Inc. helped Chinese authorities
Yahoo accused in writer’s conviction
Fort Worth Star Telegram, TX – Sep 7, 2005
By
ALEXA OLESEN. BEIJING – A French media watchdog said Tuesday that
information provided by Internet powerhouse Yahoo helped Chinese ..
Chinese writer’s jailing linked to aid by Yahoo
Baltimore Sun, United States – Sep 7, 2005
BEIJING
– A media watchdog group said yesterday that information provided by
the Internet company Yahoo Inc. helped Chinese authorities

YAHOO! BLAMED FOR HELPING JAIL CHINESE SCRIBE
New York Post, NY – Sep 7, 2005
September
7, 2005 — BEIJING — A French media watchdog said yesterday that
information provided by Internet powerhouse Yahoo! Inc.

Published by Yan Sham-Shackleton

Yan Sham-Shackleton is a Hong Kong writer who lives in Los Angeles. This is her old blog Glutter written mostly in Hong Kong from 2003 to 2007. Although it was a personal blog, Yan focused a lot on free speech issues and democratic movement in Hong Kong. She moved to the US in 2007.

8 thoughts on “Story of Yahoo!’s role in Jailing Chinese Journalist Breaks Internationally..

  1. Yahoo HK’s involvement makes me wonder is HK running on a one country one system now?
    Christian Science Monitor puts it well:
    “Legally, Yahoo is not obligated to cooperate with Chinese police. Yet in practice it may have to. Unanswered so far are the terms by which Yahoo Hong Kong, operating under the “one country two systems” formula that allows autonomy, was forced to conform to Chinese requests, despite its Hong Kong registry.”
    http://www.csmonitor.com/2005/0909/p01s03-woap.html

    Like

  2. That’s why I put up a star in your name.
    I didn’t even use the “E” word or the site coz I figured it can be traced back to you (not that they would) and you would complain!
    God I am good!
    i so know ya!

    Like

  3. PS.
    As for the CSM thing, the question is not whether it was “forced” to coopertating. I am sure it was not, but its more a simple matter of proceedure.
    All ISPs will do the same thing.
    But they need to be held accountable for such behavior, which is why getting the news out and swaying public opinions on such matters is so very important.
    yan

    Like

  4. Good stuff!
    Saw this in the FT on Thursday in our Barcelona office, actually got a mention in the office there which is more than I could say for the UK. I find more and more in the corporate culture, particularly on the US side there is less and less concern for morality, and people are reticent to raise their heads above the parapet about morally questionable business operations.
    My company has just been put through an ethics training course as part of a DOJ/SEC settlement. When I raised the issue of whether we should be doing new business with a large tobacco company, there was an uncomfortable silence in the room and the executive lead looked at his shoes and coughed. I think it is so ingrained now that things like this are done without thinking them through and it really behoves people to keep tabs on organisations to bring them up to scratch.

    Like

Leave a reply to Eshin Cancel reply