Before Sunrise Epic Greek Tragedy

I just watched Before Sunrise. The ending was not meant to be depressing when they made it. It was meant to be open ended and the audience is supposed to wonder if they meet again. But ten years later they made a second film which told us that he turned up at the train station, and she couldn’t make it because her grandmother died. That all the hopes they had, the young love they grew, the endless conversation ends up haunting them for a decade. How horrible. It’s like the most depressing movie ever I think, watching two people fall in love and know that in ten years time, she would be stuck in a relationship she’s not that passionate about, and he’s in a marriage that "feels like a small nursery," and they spent ten long years suffering over the fact that they never got to meet that person again. Uck. I am going to watch before sunset now. I thought it was a great film when i saw it a while back, but now I know the back story, I think it’s just going to be an hour and a half long exercise watching two people trying to make some sense of wasted time. As small as those two films are, as simple the concept, it’s like epic drama of Greek tragedy proportions…. so you don’t end up killing your father and sleeping with your mother, but quiet desperation is just about 100 times worse. at least with the former, you enjoyed your ten years doing it before you found out the truth followed by a quick death.

Published by Yan Sham-Shackleton

Yan Sham-Shackleton is a Hong Kong writer who lives in Los Angeles. This is her old blog Glutter written mostly in Hong Kong from 2003 to 2007. Although it was a personal blog, Yan focused a lot on free speech issues and democratic movement in Hong Kong. She moved to the US in 2007.

2 thoughts on “Before Sunrise Epic Greek Tragedy

  1. At least in the second one there is some sense that they will end up together, that they will both leave their failed relationships. At least that’s what I came away with, a feeling of inevitability, that they really were destined for each other. I enjoyed both films.
    Take care, Yan —

    Like

  2. Hi Yan
    Isn’t it just about life? There must have been many occasions where you encountered something compelling or potentially life changing but weren’t able to hold on to it because the significance wasn’t apparent at the time or you were moving in a different trajectory. Returning to that at a later point in life is a curse, I’ll give you that, but it’s only a movie.
    Actually Ethan wasn’t letting chances go when he was in Cape Town recently…

    I watched ‘Requiem for a Dream’ on the weekend. THAT depressed me for an evening.

    More phantom posts? Are they linked?

    Like

Leave a reply to Kate Cancel reply